Senate Passes Sweeping Permitting Overhaul 62-33 to Speed Energy Projects
The Senate voted 62-33 for a sweeping permitting overhaul that limits environmental lawsuits and protects issued permits. The House votes next.
The Senate on Thursday night passed a major bill aimed at cutting the red tape that slows energy and infrastructure projects. By a vote of 62-33, senators approved the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a sweeping overhaul of federal permitting for power lines, pipelines, mines, drilling, and wind and solar farms.
The bill now heads to the House. Because the Senate used a House-passed bill, H.R. 2347, as the vehicle for its text, the House must vote again on the Senate version. Republican leaders hope to send it to President Donald Trump's desk during the lame-duck session, before Democrats take control of both chambers in January.
A rare bipartisan win
The measure was negotiated by Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., and Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, the Republican chairs of the Senate's environment and energy committees, along with the top Democrats on those panels, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island and Sen. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico. The White House endorsed the bill this month.
Forty-seven Republicans voted yes. They were joined by 15 members of the Democratic caucus, including Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, independent Sen. Angus King of Maine and Arizona Sen. Ruben Gallego. Thirty-one Democrats voted no, along with two Republicans, Sen. Josh Hawley of Missouri and Sen. Mike Rounds of South Dakota.
"Tonight, the passage of permitting reform in the Senate finally became reality and we took a major step towards addressing the affordability concerns of the American people," Capito said after the vote.
What the bill does
Builders have long complained that the National Environmental Policy Act, known as NEPA, buries projects in years of paperwork and lawsuits. The bill takes direct aim at that.
- Deadlines on reviews. The bill keeps the limits set in 2023 law, two years for a full environmental review and one year for a shorter one, and adds new deadlines for the steps before and after the review.
- A shorter window to sue. NEPA challenges would have to be filed within 150 days, down from the six-year window that generally applies today, and would go straight to a federal appeals court.
- Permits stay in effect. If a court finds a flaw that violates only NEPA, it can send the approval back to the agency to fix, but it cannot cancel the permit or halt the project.
- Permit certainty. Agencies could not revoke or reopen a valid permit except in limited cases, such as fraud, a court order or a material violation by the permit holder.
The bill would also expand the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's power to approve interstate transmission lines. A section called the Ratepayer Protection Act is meant to make data centers pay for their own grid upgrades instead of passing the costs to families.
Supporters say the stakes are large. In floor remarks earlier this month, Capito cited McKinsey data showing $1.8 trillion in investments locked up in the federal permitting system, and National Association of Manufacturers figures showing permitting delays cost manufacturers $12.1 billion a year.
The American Petroleum Institute called the vote a "major breakthrough on historic permitting reforms that would deliver more affordable energy for consumers, cut costly delays, and build much-needed critical infrastructure."
Concerns on both sides
Not every conservative is on board. Hawley said the bill's transmission provisions threaten private land through eminent domain.
"Legislation that threatens to take farmers' land is legislation I won't support," Hawley said in a statement.
The bill would also let developers go to court if an administration singles out certain types of energy for unfair treatment. That provision is aimed in part at the Trump administration's efforts to block or delay wind and solar projects. Some Democrats said that is part of the appeal. "It's going to be legislation that's really going to make the biggest difference for the next 100 years, especially bringing down carbon emissions once this president is gone," Gallego told reporters before the vote, CNBC reported.
On the left, the Natural Resources Defense Council urged the House to reject what it called "a blank check to reward oil and gas companies and data center developers." Rep. Jared Huffman, D-Calif., the likely next chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, urged Democrats to vote no, saying, "We can produce a better deal."
The House is next
House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., has said the bill can pass the House, and some House Democrats, including Rep. Scott Peters of California, support it. House action is expected after the Thanksgiving recess.
The window is narrow. Once the new Democratic majorities are sworn in, leading opponents such as Sen. Jeff Merkley, D-Ore., and Huffman are in line to chair key committees. For Republicans who have pushed for years to speed up federal permitting, the next few weeks may be their best chance.